Santa Barbara
69° F
Santa Maria
65° F
San Luis Obispo
64° F
67° F

Closing arguments heard in Myers murder trial

By Andrew Gray, NewsChannel 3 Reporter,
Published On: Mar 21 2013 10:07:58 PM CDT
Updated On: Mar 21 2013 11:01:35 PM CDT

Jury begins deliberation


It has been an emotional two weeks in the Dystiny Myers murder trial. The prosecution and defense presented their closing arguments Thursday and the defense asked for a mistrial which was denied by the judge. Now the jury will decide the fate of Rhonda Wisto and Jacob York.

The jury has heard testimony from 40 people and will have more than 200 pieces of evidence to go through.

The prosecution says it should have no problems finding both defendants guilty.

In the prosecution's closing argument it leaned heavily on testimony from Jason Greenwell and letters written in jail from York and Wisto. It showed evidence of York admitting to being involved in her death.

The evidence presented against Wisto was a little different. The prosecution painted her as the ring leader in how she made the decisions that led up to Myers’ death.

“Greenwell tells you at that point, Jacob York told his mom he didn’t want to do it. Jason Greenwell didn’t make that up. He said that York didn’t want to do it. Jason Greenwell said that Rhonda Wisto said sometimes things just have to happen,” said Prosecutor Tim Covello.

Wisto’s attorney closed by stating Jason Greenwell is a serial liar and everything he said is not true. “If you believe that Jason Greenwell is telling the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth, if that is what he is doing, if that’s your finding, then you should find my client guilty when it’s all said and done,” said Michael Cummens, Wisto’s attorney.

He stated that Wisto’s DNA and fingerprints were not found anywhere.

York’s attorney argued that his client was too intoxicated on meth to form any intent so he should not be found guilty of all charges.

The jury began deliberations just after 4 p.m. Thursday afternoon.


The views expressed are not those of this company or its affiliated companies. Please note by clicking on "Post" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms Of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. 
blog comments powered by Disqus
  • Body of Isaiah Sanchez Recovered at Cachuma Lake

    Santa Barbara County sheriff rescue crews have found a body near the place where Isaiah Sanchez went missing.

  • Ellwood Fire

    Explosion at Goleta Apartment Complex Leaves One Man Hospitalized

    Santa Barbara County Fire crews responded to an explosion and fire at an apartment complex on 447 Ellwood Drive in Goleta.   Fire officials received the call at around 7:00 p.m. One person was injured and taken to the hospital with severe burns.  The apartment manager helped put out a small fire that broke out after the blast. The explosion and fire are still under investigation.  The fire did not spread to any adjoining apartments.

  • dangerous dogs

    Orcutt Family Starts Petition to Change County Ordinance

    An Orcutt family is fighting to keep their dogs from being euthanized, and is now trying to change a county ordinance on aggressive dogs. The family has an online petition spreading their message on the internet in an effort to get the Santa Barbara County Board of Supervisor's attention.

    Peggy Henning remembers the day her family welcomed Daisy and Duke into their family like it was yesterday.

    "They immediately just became part of the family," said Henning. "They were very friendly with all the guests we had coming over."

    But things changed when Daisy and Duke got loose. They liked chasing cats.

    "Dogs are pack animals and that is their default instinct," said Henning. "If they are bonded or litter mates, it intensifies that. They would get out of the confines of our house or yard and this instinct would come to the surface."

  • motorcycle_police_officer

    Drivers Stung in a Sting Come Close to Hitting Pedestrians

    A crackdown on drivers who won't stop for pedestrians in a crosswalk is underway in Santa Barbara and Goleta.

  • Explosion Caused By Man Producing Marijuana Oil

    Explosion Caused By Man Producing Marijuana Oil

    Investigators said the Goleta apartment explosion and fire Monday night was caused by the illegal process of making butane honey oil.

  • Santa Paula Reserve Police Officer Resigns After Posting Video About Bicyclists

    Volunteer posted a YouTube video joking about running over bicyclists.

  • Juvenile Hall Court to Host Gang-related Murder Trial

    The so-called "U-Haul murder trial" is expected to be another high security, gang-related trial that requires extra time and money to make it work at the Santa Barbara County Juvenile Hall courtroom which is seen as the most practical venue.

  • Stone Named Interim Head Football Coach for Dons

    JT Stone Will Serve as Interim Head Football Coach at Santa Barbara High School

    Stone has 14 years of coaching experience at the youth and high school level.

  • Slideshow: Rescue Crews Find Body In Cachuma Lake

    Santa Barbara County sheriff rescue crews have found a body near the place where Isaiah Sanchez went missing.

  • Slideshow: Blondes VS Brunettes Charity Football Game

    A charity football game at the Polo fields in Carpinteria pits the Blondes vs Brunettes. The all-women football teams duked it out on Saturday to raise funds for the Alzheimer's Association. Both teams fought fiercely but in the end, only one came out the victor.

    Photography by Oscar Flores.