Santa Barbara
70° F
Santa Maria
53° F
San Luis Obispo
53° F
58° F

Airline merger lawsuits may not help consumers

Published On: Aug 23 2013 10:54:31 AM CDT
US Airways jet landing

Joel Page / Reuters

By attorney Joshua Ferraro, Special to THELAW.TV

For more than a century, it has been the public policy of the United States to stop corporate mergers and acquisitions that pose a threat to the competitive nature of the free market.

The conventional wisdom has been that the merger of industry leaders results in less competition, higher prices and less accountability to the American consumer. Therefore, from the trust busting days of Teddy Roosevelt (who famously broke up the railroad monopoly held by J. P. Morgan) to the breakup of AT&T in the 1980's, the American people have made it clear that anti-competitive monopolies will not be tolerated.

Against this backdrop, American Airlines and US Airways recently proposed an $11 billion merger that would make them the exclusive major carrier at seven non-stop routes and the leading carrier at several major airports. The proposed merger would help the airlines stay financially solvent in a historically difficult industry. But, according to the Department of Justice, it would do so at the expense of tens of millions of passengers who might be negatively affected. As a result, the Department of Justice and six state attorney generals filed suit in federal district court to block the merger.

The Department of Justice claims that the proposed merger would create the world's largest airline, which would substantially reduce competition in the industry. The DOJ also claims that the two airlines are currently the only major competing airlines on more than one thousand routes and that by eliminating this competition, fares on these routes will likely increase.

The airlines' attorneys point out that the merger provides substantial benefits to employees and shareholders, as well as the combined company's customer base. They also note that with other major airlines allowed to merge in recent years, this is as much a marriage of necessity as anything else (a point that seems to be validated by the fact that American Airlines is currently in bankruptcy).

Therefore, the airlines claim this merger would actually increase -- or at least help to maintain -- competition by ensuring that all of the major carriers remain financially viable entities.

At the end of the day, it is impossible to predict whether this particular merger will benefit or harm consumers on issues of airfares, fees, route availability and general customer service. Likewise, it is impossible to predict whether the DOJ suit will be successful (several antitrust experts have opined that it is a weak case and pointed out that the government is rarely successful when bringing these cases to trial). That said, we can predict with virtual certainty that, whatever the outcome, this will be a long and drawn out process with the American consumer caught in the middle.

The author, Joshua Ferraro, is an attorney at the West Palm Beach, Fla., personal injury law firm of Lesser, Lesser, Landy & Smith.


The views expressed are not those of this company or its affiliated companies. Please note by clicking on "Post" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms Of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. 
blog comments powered by Disqus
  • fatal_accident_investigation

    Extensive Investigation into Triple Fatal Accident

    An extensive investigation is underway to determine the cause of death in a triple fatal rollover accident Monday morning in Santa Barbara.

  • Triple Fatal Auto Accident on Highway

    3 Dead In Early Morning Accident, Driver Arrested For DUI

    The 101 southbound through Santa Barbara reopened just before 12:30 Monday afternoon as authorities investigate what they say was a deadly two car DUI accident.

  • fuzion_store_business_santa_barbara

    UCSB Group Boycotts Business For Promoting Deltopia

    A UCSB student group is boycotting a local business for creating the Deltopia Facebook page, which they said brought in thousands of outsiders to the small college town.

  • girl_child_coughing_sick_whooping_cough

    Contagious Diseases Making a Comeback in California

    Deadly diseases that were a thing of the past are making a comeback in California.

  • Witnesses to Fatal Crash

    Eyewitnesses See Triple Fatal Crash from Roadside Camp

    A homeless couple watching the freeway from their campsite in Santa Barbara this morning, witnessed the triple fatal accident that took the lives of two teens and a young man.

  • Triple Fatal Auto Accident on Highway

    DUI Driver in Fatal Early Morning Accident Ordered to Detox Program in 1995

    The Santa Barbara woman arrested for DUI in the early morning accident that left three people dead early Monday morning has a lengthy court record out of Ventura County. Kimberly Kreis, 52, was ordered to serve 30 days in a detox program as far back as 1995.

    The car that Kreis was driving crashed into a disabled Mazda near the Castillo off-ramp of the southbound 101 freeway in Santa Barbara. Two 17 year old North Torrance High School students were killed in the accident- Jessica Leffew and Danielle Murillo. 20 year old Brian Lopez also died in the wreck. The driver of the Mazda, Eric August, is hospitalized in critical condition.

    A NewsChannel 3 investigation found records out of Ventrua County that appear to show that Greis has at least one prior conviction involving drugs and or alcohol, and in 1995 she was ordered to serve 30 days in a Cottage Hospital detox program.

    CHP investigators are still trying to piece together why the Mazda veered right into a guardrail, causing it to flip onto it's roof before coming to rest in the middle of the southbound freeway, which set into motion the deadly accident.

    CHP Officer Jonathan Guiterrez, said "A lot of things could have happened, He could have fallen asleep. We just don't know at this point."

  • Parents of Mallory Dies Sue Congresswoman, Her Former Aide, and U.S. Government

    The parents of a young Santa Barbara woman killed in a high profile, DUI case are suing Congresswoman Lois Capps, her former aide Raymond Morua, and the U-S government in federal court.

  • Larry Lee Cal Poly Coach

    Cal Poly Baseball Earns No. 1 National Ranking

    The Mustangs achieved the school's second No. 1 national ranking in Division I as Collegiate Baseball Newspaper has placed Cal Poly atop its Top 30.

  • Lupita Nyong'o

    REUTERS/Danny Moloshok

    People's 'World's Most Beautiful' list 2014

    People magazine recently named Lupita Nyong'o its "World's Most Beautiful" for 2014. See which other ladies earned a coveted spot on the annual list.

  • Slideshow: Extensive Investigation into Triple Fatal Accident

    An extensive investigation is underway to determine the cause of death in a triple fatal rollover accident Monday morning in Santa Barbara.